10/11/2019 by Zach Lesage
Your opponent just tried to double attach, you think to yourself, did they attach already this turn?!?! You ask your opponent, they respond with a red face and apologize saying that they forgot. They are about to continue on with their turn and you are upset because something feels wrong... I am Zach Lesage, one of the managing partners for 60 Cards, and I want to share some tips today that will help make you realize what to do in a weird situation. It sucks to call judge over because it creates for an awkward moment between you and your opponent, but you need to understand that the Judges at events are there to help. It isn’t really a negative thing, it is the best protection for an honest game of Pokemon. The above situation happens to many players, mostly newer players, because they didn’t realize that it is their duty to stop the game and let their opponent know that they broke the game state. In that scenario, it might sound like our hypothetical opponent is just being forgetful, but what if it is a cheater who just got caught? I’m not a Judge, you might not be a Judge, and your opponent is hopefully not a Judge... You wanna know who is a Judge though? The Judge is a Judge and they are there to *calmly* find a solution. If you don’t call Judges, games are unfair, tournaments end up having different results through ripple effects, and the cheaters walk away with prize money. In this article, I will detail the steps on how to prevent “broken game states” by properly assessing situations and calling a Judge over. If you think you are experiencing déjà vu, this is a re-released article just in time for this weekend! If you want to read some of our other great articles, considering picking up a subscription by using code bf60cards to save some money!
Table of contents
The following steps should help you learn to call a Judge in any scenario so let’s get there.
You have obviously realized that something is going wrong in the game and it is best to stop the game exactly where it is right now! If you wait until your opponent shuffles their hand into the deck with Cynthia (UPR; 119) or if you remember a turn too late, you may be at fault for breaking the game state just as much as your opponent. The best way to do this is to flat out tell your opponent that you believe there is an issue with the game and that you want them to stop their play to resolve this. If you are playing at an event versus a player who speaks a different language than you or if any additional special assistance is required, call for either a translator and / or assistance. Explain to them that you would like your opponent to stop the game and to help translate with the opponent. In any case, it is best to treat a situation such as this with respect to your opponent and not to accuse them right away!
So you think your opponent just drew an extra card from Heat Factory Prism Star (LT; 178) , but you aren’t sure, and you are worried that you might be imagining things. That’s ok! I often ask my opponent their hand size every few turns or so, I look through their Discard Pile, and I frequently ask questions. In any case, you need to nicely and I can’t stress that enough. Ask your opponent if they drew an extra card, that’s the easiest way to do it. In most cases, they will just say whoops and ask what to do next. You may be playing against the newest player in the game, a friend, a cheater, or one of the greatest players of all time -- it doesn’t matter. Let them know that you need to call a Judge to figure out the best way to fix the game state. Most opponents should be fine with this, but I have had opponents argue with me, intimidate me to not call a Judge over, or get upset at me for not trusting them. The absolute best resolution will always come from a Judge so I recommend to always call for a Judge when something goes wrong.
This step is essential in making sure that a Judge notices you -- the best thing to do is to put your hand up as high as possible. Sometimes Judges might think a player is just scratching their back, but they are actually trying to call a Judge with the laziest raised hand of all time! If you have been waiting for a while, it is appropriate to call out ‘JUDGE’ in a firm way, but not to yell it either. A Judge should quickly address that you have called over for a Judge and come over to your table right away!
Breathe! If you start jumping up and down thinking you found a cheater like the leprechauns on cereal boxes just found a new marshmallow flavour, you are not going to get anywhere! If you ask questions appropriately, state facts calmly, and show everyone respect, rules are much more likely to go in your direction. This might not always work, but it is better to be chill than irate, which I am sure every event staff member will appreciate. Confidently state your case, only talk when you are addressed, let your opponent talk when they are addressed, and receive your ruling. If you believe the ruling is incorrect or unfair, you can ask the Judge if they are the Head Judge of the event to see if you can escalate the ruling process. This isn’t meant to be disrespectful, but Judges are human and they can still make mistakes. When the Head Judge comes to the table, confirm they are the Head Judge, and re-state your case. No matter which way the ruling goes, be respectful to your opponent, the Judges, and the Head Judge.
Sometimes players will have an important ruling and it will take a bunch of time. Whether the ruling takes two minutes or ten minutes, you should always politely ask for a time extension from the staff member that you were dealing with. I can count many games that I have heard of players losing or getting a tie from a ruling just because they never asked for a time extension. Like anything, if you don’t ask, you might not receive so always keep that door open.
Finally, when a ruling happens, you gotta thank the people involved! About a year ago at the Oaks, PA Regionals, I received a Game Loss as per the ‘New Rules’ due to having my only Tapu Lele GX (GRI; 60) in my deck being warped. This penalty fell under ‘Marked Cards’ and I received a Game Loss heading into Round 9! They deemed it as unintentional, but the minimal penalty was still a Game Loss. What did I do?!?!... I actually thanked the Judges for making the correct call; even though it was a call that took me out of contention for advancing further in the tournament. In any case, always be professional and always being respectful will go a long ways.
Ok, so you know how to call a Judge and why to call a Judge, but how do you know something fishy is going on? Well, you gotta have eyes like a hawk in order to stop the sneakiest players from getting away with whatever they want. During my second round of the Mexico City Special Event this season, I noticed that my opponent’s Tapu Lele GX (GRI; 60) seemed look different than his other cards. I asked my opponent if I could see that card on his Bench and I realized that the card was double sleeved. Looking at his other cards, I quickly found out that his other cards were not double sleeved. That meant my opponent could gain an advantage by having varying thickness of cards in their deck which can be manipulated to their advantage. I immediately stopped the game, told my opponent what happened, and called over a Judge! Maybe my opponent made a mistake, but maybe they were trying to cheat against me. You need to pay attention to your opponent when they play instead of looking at your friend playing their game right beside you when it is your opponents turn. Furthermore, after every deck shuffling action your opponent does, you should alternate the way you cut, shuffle, or tap their deck to offset any potential stacking techniques they could use against you. I will shuffle and cut my own teammates deck and they are some of the most honest players I know! If you are watching your opponent for any weird plays, you will often become more developed in the game and see other plays too just from noticing what your opponent is doing on a deeper level! Just remember to call a Judge if you see any sneaky actions!
Well that’s a wrap for today. This is my last article for the week, phew I think I wrote four, and I hope it is helpful heading into this weekend. I might actually end up posting a video from Rare Candy on the site, but that is to be determined by our upload schedule. We have big plans here at 60Cards and I hope you can absorb as much information from some upcoming exciting news. As for me, I finished registering and booking flights for every major event in North America (and Latin American Internationals) all the way up until San Diego! I’m excited to play Pokémon, prove to myself that I am one of the best players in the game, and see all of my friends who play this game. After going 3-1-1 at Worlds Day Two to 3-3-1, it took me a couple of days to come down from the level of disappointment that I felt. While I can’t be certain that I will have a fulfilling finish at Worlds this year, or any tournament for that season, I will use my hope as a fuel to push myself as far ahead as I can. I have already earned 335CP and I don’t plan on stopping soon. Anyways, as I continue on my Pokemon adventure, feel free to follow me on all of my social media. See ya in Knoxville.
Facebook: Zach Lesage
Youtube: Rare Candy TCG
I also have open slots for coaching so if you are interested, please reach out to me on Twitter or Facebook.
Tapu Lele GX (GRI; 60)
Cynthia (UPR; 119)
Heat Factory Prism Star (LT; 178)
Thank you for your time. Please leave us your feedback to help us to improve the articles for you!
Pokémon and its trademarks are ©1995-2018 Nintendo, Creatures, and GAMEFREAK. English card images appearing on this website are the property of The Pokémon Company International, Inc. 60cards is a fan site. Our goal is to promote the Pokemon TCG and help it grow. We are not official in any shape or form, nor affiliated, sponsored, or otherwise endorsed by Nintendo, Creatures, GAMEFREAK, or TPCi.